Google Project Fi vs Other Carriers: What’s the Best Deal?

Google is shaking things up with Project Fi, its newly announced wireless service for smartphones that could put a scare into both major and discount carriers. With a tantalizingly low cost (starting at $30 per month), the combined strength of two cellular networks as a backbone (Sprint and T-Mobile), international texting and the ability to enable calls and texts across devices, Project Fi offers plenty of incentives for customers to jump ship. Plus, Google will give you a credit for unused data, as opposed to just rolling it over to the next month like T-Mobile and AT&T.


Smartphone Selection
Google Nexus 6
Dozens, from flagships to budget options
Dozens, from flagships to budget options Dozens, from flagships to budget options Dozens, from flagships to budget options Dozens, from flagships to budget options Dozens, mostly mid-level options
3, starting at $29

Data Overage Costs
$10 / 1 GB (or $1 / 100MB
$20 / 500MB
None
None (data drops to 3G speeds) $15 / 500MB
None (data drops to 3G speeds) None (data drops to 3G speeds) None (data drops to 3G speeds)


* Calculations based on plan with unlimited talk, text with 1GB of data; Sprint plan provides unlimited data with $50 monthly fee available for iPhone users; Boost's most comparable plan offers 2GB of data while Cricket offers 2.5GB.


** $45 cost is for phones bought through Verizon Edge; otherwise, the monthly fee is $60 for Verizon


Simply put, Project Fi is a wireless service provider from Google. So instead of seeing AT&T, Sprint, T-Mobile or Verizon's operator logos on your phone, you'll see the Fi Network. Google's service will ride on T-Mobile and Sprint networks, switching between the two depending on which signal is stronger. Project Fi also taps into more than 3 million Wi-Fi hotspots, and Google says that its integrated encryption will keep your data safe.


Project Fi also lets you send and receive texts and calls from your Google account on any device with Hangouts installed, such as your laptop or tablet, if you opt-in to this feature. You'll also get unlimited international texting to and from 120-plus countries as well as free international data roaming.

Keep in mind that for now the Nexus 6 ($649 or $27.04 per month) is the only smartphone that’s compatible with Project Fi. It’s a solid flagship handset, but the huge 6-inch display certainly isn’t for everyone.
Google Fi vs AT&T and Verizon

Both AT&T and Verizon are more expensive up front, at $65 and $45 ($60 if you don't sign up for Verizon's early-upgrade plan Edge) respectively. While AT&T does offer free international texting, Verizon doesn't, and data roaming comes at extra cost. Both major carriers also charge overages when you exceed your allotted bandwidth, whereas Project Fi just charges you a dollar for each 100 MB you've used.

AT&T and Verizon both offer plenty more smartphone options than Project Fi does, and each company has a larger 4G footprint than Sprint and T-Mobile, covering most of the United States. Verizon also came in first for speed in New York City, Chicago and San Francisco in our 4G tests in major cities, while AT&T placed third in San Francisco, NYC and Chicago, and second in Los Angeles. Since Project Fi picks the stronger network between Sprint and T-Mobile and leverages Wi-Fi when available, though, carrier speeds might not be that big of an issue.


Google Fi vs Sprint

On Sprint, you can pick an unlimited data plan for $60 a month or sign up for a 1GB Share Pack plan as an individual, which will cost you $15 more than it would on Project Fi. While Sprint's unlimited plan is a compelling value, keep in mind that its plodding network may drive you up the wall. The carrier ranked last in three out of four of our 4G performance tests in major American cities, although its Spark-enhanced LTE service helped it secure second place in Chicago. But Spark only reaches about 100 markets right now.

Though Project Fi does harness Sprint's channels, it also uses T-Mobile, so you'll have the power of two networks. Sprint offers free international text and data roaming for qualified customers and caps overseas data at 2G speeds, whereas Project Fi's international data goes up to 3G.

Like T-Mobile, Sprint will pay your early termination fees if you're switching over, so those who are locked into a contract and want unlimited data may want to consider Sprint.
Google Fi vs T-Mobile

T-Mobile's basic Simple Choice plan starts at $50 for unlimited talk and text with 1GB of data, which is $20 more than the same plan on Project Fi. But the Uncarrier packs a lot of goodies into its lines, such as unlimited free music streaming, unlimited international texts and free data roaming.

While Project Fi also offers unlimited international texts and international data without roaming fees, data speeds will be capped at 3G rates outside the U.S. T-Mobile's option offers 4G speeds where available as well as free international W-Fi Calling on compatible phones.


T-Mobile also has plenty of phone options, which is another advantage over Fi, and it will pay your early termination fees if you switch over from another carrier. Google will not pay your switching fees. But over the long term, Project Fi can save you money.
Google Fi vs MetroPCS

Same price, same data allowance -- Project Fi and MetroPCS are almost identical in their 1GB offerings. But Google gives you money back for your unused data, meaning potential cost savings over time. And when you exceed your data allowance, you can pay for more 4G data instead of being dropped to 3G speeds on MetroPCS. But at least Metro doesn't have overages.


Only 3 phones are compatible with MetroPCS's low-tier package, however, and they're lower-power, entry-level options (LG Optimus L70, Kyocera Hydro Life, Alcatel Onetouch Fierce 2). Project Fi is only compatible with the Nexus 6 ($650) right now, and you can buy one from Fi either at full price or over 24 monthly payments of $27.04.
Google Fi vs Boost Mobile and Cricket Wireless

Prepaid carriers Boost Mobile and Cricket Wireless both offer more data than Project Fi does at the $30-$35 level. Boost gives you 2GB for $30 a month, Cricket offers 2.5GB for $35, and both plans come with unlimited talk and text. That's at least twice the 1GB you get on Project Fi for $30. You'll also find a wider selection of phones from both companies, with Boost even offering such flagships as the Galaxy S6.

But neither Boost nor Cricket offer unlimited international texting, and you have to enroll in both carriers' automatic bill payment service to qualify for these prices. After reaching your data limit, both Boost and Cricket drop your data transmissions to 2G speeds.

Boost's $30 for 2GB deal is only valid if you sign up before May 31, 2015.
Bottom Line

If you want the flexibility of using your phone number on all your devices and you travel a lot, Project Fi could be the carrier for you. Its costs and data allowances are comparable to plenty of packages already available. However, if you’re fond of your existing phone, you may want to stick with your current carrier: Project Fi is available only on the Nexus 6 for now.

Data sharks on a budget may be better served with Cricket Wireless's $35 plan with 2.5GB of high-speed bandwidth. Frequent travelers who want better data speeds abroad should consider T-Mobile But if you’re looking for a lower-cost alternative to AT&T and Verizon -- and you’re okay with carrying a big phablet -- Project Fi could be worth a look.